Review | Pale Rose of England by Sandra Worth

Paperback: 464 pages
Publisher: Berkley Trade
Release Date: February 1st, 2011
Source: I received this ARC from the publisher for review.

One of the most controversial subjects in historical fiction covering English history is the mystery of the Princes in the Tower. A polarizing topic, authors and readers alike seem to be hotly divided not only as to who, if anyone, killed the young York heirs, but also the proper manner in which to broach this subject matter in literature. Those who may not be as familiar with this period in history may want to check out this post in order to become better acquainted with the situation.

Sandra Worth’s latest novel takes the controversial stance that Richard, second in line to the throne at the time Edward VI’s death, survived the ordeal of the Tower of London, living abroad under the name Perkin Warbeck. Historically, during Henry VII’s reign there was a pretender to the throne named Perkin Warbeck who claimed to be Richard and presented himself at many of the European courts as such, though he was later found to be a fraud. As the possibility still remains that the man truly was who he claimed to be, Pale Rose of England creatively takes the “what if” route and explores “Richard’s” life as he dangerously attempts to reclaim his throne. All the while, his wife Lady Catherine Gordon, a beautiful Scottish noblewoman, accompanies him on his quest.

While imaginative, the book was a bit too far-fetched for me. I went into this read with an open mind, but I wasn’t convinced that Perkin Warbeck was in fact Richard, Duke of York. This, coupled with the fact that I didn’t find Richard a strong enough hero for me to truly “root for” him, made the book less engaging for me. The antagonists were also just too evil, with very little balance. Henry VII had no redeeming qualities whatsoever, which felt artificial. I’m also slightly bothered that, while the cover is stunning (truly, it is), it’s not at all historically accurate. I know the art department is usually to blame for this as authors typically have no say in their cover art, but that high, starched ruff collar was not in fashion until the mid-16th century, after Catherine’s death.

I did find the love story touching, the period detail exemplary, and the overall concept of the book interesting. I also appreciated learning about a heroine not previously covered in other historical fiction novels. Much of the book takes place after Richard’s death, and Catherine certainly had a fascinating life. I’ve not read any of Worth’s other books, though I’ve heard good things. Based on the quality of the research that went into this book, I would definitely be open to reading more from this author.

Purchase this book on Amazon | Purchase this book from an Indie Bookseller